Proceed at your own risk
By KIM SMITH DEDAM
Staff Writer
Having interviewed medical and rescue people repeatedly over the past several years about communications issues in the Adirondacks, I find their answers are sounding a lot like a broken record.
It’s at the point where people just want to put up a sign somewhere before the Pottersville exit on I-87 North: “Proceed at your own risk.”
Not because our first-response people aren’t great, because they are.
The accidents are too grim, people can’t call for help quickly, and EMTs can make up only so much time in the race to get there.
If you knew how dedicated and caring they are, you’d know the other crime being committed by duplicitous efforts keeping new technology from reaching the depths of the Adirondacks.
The EMTs would give you the shirt off their back; they’ve done that, in fact. They’d go get you gas. They’d change your tire.
But the whole debacle smacks of other things left out of the region: health-care options, business and industry, fair wages, good grocery stores.
Gas costs about $2.48 a gallon.
Some guy came into the store after buying gas one day and complained, saying he’d paid $1.68 per gallon when he left New Jersey.
I’ve learned that insurance companies redline this area because they can’t make money here; it’s too risky. But I can’t prove it, so I can’t write about it.
I’ve learned that one wireless company in a fight to put up cell towers told its competitors not to build the system on the Northway because they would never get a share of the market. But I can’t prove it, so I can’t write about it.
Nobody wants to discuss what hangs on the fringe of poverty. It’s too dirty and conjures up images of ketchup, kerosene and mice.
Decisions like these are made behind vaulted doors with long combinations.
There’s no such thing as open-door profits.
And it’s capitalism’s inner world that drives political sentiment.
People have caved to Gov. Eliot Spitzer’s claim that this is “Appalachia north,” which is wrong by definition.
The Adirondack Mountains are nothing like the Appalachians even if they erupted at the same time. These ridges are made of garnet and iron and anorthacite, the oldest rock on Earth.
There’s no doing business here, we hear. There’s nothing to do.
Standing in Essex County Court on break from covering a trial a few weeks ago, one visitor from elsewhere asked, “What do you do here?”
I laughed, I really did, before pointing out how much history was within eyesight of the court window.
“But you have to slow down enough to see it. You also have to like being outdoors.”
There’s a snowshoe trail on the golf course and good sledding hills, a couple small ski areas within spitting distance.
I’ve had people stop and ask me as I walked through E’town if there’s anywhere to hike.
“Pick a direction, east, south, west or north,” I laughed, incredulous.
Police have told me about people calling from the dark Northway claiming they to be lost, even though they can only go north or south on what is principally a straight line to Canada.
Other people wonder why we’re allowed to live on state land.
We don’t.
Only about half the land inside the blue line is state-owned.
We pay taxes just like you. And the state doesn’t pay the same as we do in taxes, either, I might add.
The people were here before the state land and before the Adirondack Park Agency.
The Adirondack Park doesn’t have gates, it doesn’t have a bunch of fake rides and it doesn’t have lights.
It costs something to get in, though.
It costs a lack of modernity.
So if there’s a way through the catch-22 of rural-keeping for lackluster capitalist desire, I’d like to write about it.
I think it would take a special kind of investor to get it.
They’d get some good neighbors, but nobody cares about that anymore.
I’m pretty sure the answer isn’t in real estate, since a lot of the newly rich need things like cell phones and broadband and wireless.
I asked a developer who owns lots on the other side of Whiteface who he was planning to sell to.
“Don’t they require a remote control for their living room?” I asked.
He didn’t think it was funny and didn’t answer, so I couldn’t write about it.
He did ask me, “Do you ever think they’ll put a cell tower on top of Whiteface?”
I laughed.
“They did that once and had to take it down. It was illegal.”
His response was a deadened, “Oh.”
Maybe we could attach tiny wireless chips to blackflies and at least get service for half the year.
Or maybe we should post the Northway: “Proceed at your own risk.”
Search

Comments
Although I'm not there any longer, I grew up in Keeseville and left less than 10 years ago. I try to keep up with the news "back home", with the P-R being my main source. Being a native of the North Country and the Adirondack Park, I've done my fair share of defending the area (where appropriate) and joining criticism (where necessary). The recent news regarding cell reception on the Northway has particularly piqued my interest. You see, I've always debated within myself and with others whether the area deserves the "reputation" of being undeveloped, uncivilized and downright devoid of any modernization.
With this cell issue, my initial reaction is one of defiance--that this recent spate was prompted by a community in NYC and it hasn't been until now that the issue has been given serious "something must be done now" attention. I have an innate temptation to remind travelers of where they are and that not all the luxuries of home may be available. After all, is there cell service in the plains of the midwest or deserts of the southwest? If not, where is the outcry? Common sense people, common sense. I'm sure I'm not the first to ask this question, but what did we do before cell phones? I am no luddite; I agree that we should modernize to the extent possible. However, it doesn't happen overnight and there are places today and will be well into the future that will lag behind...and the Northway is one of them. So, travelers (a/k/a downstaters), don't be so quick to criticize the "primacy" of the communications on the Northway.
Second, one important point is that there hasn't been much discussion distinguishing between what types of cell providers do and don't receive service on the Northway (Pottersville north). I use Cingular and recently drove the Northway to visit family in Keeseville. While there were outages, they weren't as widespread as the media would have us think. The most prominent dead spot was from about Keene to Lewis. True enough, while this stretch may be were the recent events ocurred, it still debunks the claim of media and critics that there is NO service on the Northway. As an analogy, I recently visited NC to see my in-laws. It just so happened that my cell wouldn't work on the towers there. As a result, I couldn't call the office and check messages, etc. While a less extreme example, I still think there is value in using it for comparative purposes.
Posted by: Matt Bergeron | February 21, 2007 4:59 PM
I agree with Matt. There are cell outages, but there is not an outright lack of coverage. In addition, as one intimately acquainted with the hospitality-tourism aspect of things in the region, I can tell you that many of the NYC and city-slicker crowd who come to the region revel in being able to turn off their cell phones! Many, even when they find thay can get coverage, opt to turn it off and enjoy getting back in touch with a slower pace, and unreachable status. That is part of the charm and abiance of getting away to the Adirondacks.
We cannot in one argument legislate every aspect of our lives, require every square mile be coated in modern technology and convenience, and then in the next demand smaller government and lower taxes. We grieve the loss of human life, and yet we are grateful for the beauty surounding us in the region and realize that we make trade offs to live here.
Posted by: KarenMarie | February 24, 2007 10:08 AM